Explore Luxury Camping: 10 Best Glamping Sites in New York, According To Reddit
New York surprises a lot of people. Most travelers picture the city — the subway grids, the rooftops, the concrete. But a few hours north and west, the state unfolds into something else entirely: misty Catskill hollows, Finger Lakes wine country, Adirondack forests that stretch uninterrupted for six million acres. Reddit's outdoor travel communities have spent years quietly mapping the best places to experience all of it without giving up the comforts of a hotel. These are the ten glamping sites they keep recommending.
1. Eastwind Hotel & Bar — Windham, Catskills
Scandinavian-inspired mountain retreat | Windham, NY
Eastwind is the Catskills glamping name that appears most often across Reddit travel communities, and for good reason. Converted from a 1920s bunkhouse, the property offers stylish "Lushnas" — compact A-frame cabins with real beds, loft sleeping, full en-suite bathrooms, outdoor showers, and hammocks strung between birch trees. The cocktail bar and communal sauna make it feel like a boutique hotel that simply happens to sit in the mountain woods.
Reddit couples specifically praise Eastwind for threading the needle between genuine nature immersion and genuine comfort — without the performative rusticity that undermines some luxury camping properties.
Reddit verdict: "Eastwind is the best thing in the Catskills right now. Lushna cabin, sauna, cocktail bar — we never wanted to leave."
2. Firelight Camps — Ithaca, Finger Lakes
Safari tents beside Buttermilk Falls | Ithaca, NY
Firelight Camps earns consistent Reddit praise as the standout glamping destination in the Finger Lakes region. Spacious safari-style tents with hardwood floors, proper beds, and warm lighting sit near Buttermilk Falls State Park. An on-site camp lounge and bar covers the social evening; hiking, wineries, and waterfalls cover the days.
Reddit glamping threads identify Firelight as one of New York's most complete experiences — accommodation, setting, and activities all working together in a way that doesn't require a car to cobble together. The restaurant on-site receives repeated praise from Redditors who note it operates at a quality level that would be impressive in any city.
Reddit verdict: "Firelight Camps in Ithaca hit every note. Safari tent with real beds, incredible falls nearby, great on-site bar. Book it."
3. Collective Retreats — Governors Island, NYC
Manhattan skyline glamping six months a year | New York City
For anyone unwilling to leave the city but wanting something genuinely different, Collective Retreats on Governors Island is Reddit's consistent recommentation. Open seasonally from late spring through fall, the property offers Summit Tents with private bathrooms, spa soaking tubs, and king beds — with views of the Statue of Liberty and lower Manhattan skyline that no hotel room at any price point can fully replicate.
Journey Tents offer a more paired-back experience with shared bathrooms, but Reddit's NYC outdoor communities overwhelmingly book the Summit Tents for the full luxury effect. Continental breakfast is included. A free ferry connects the island to Manhattan in minutes.
Reddit verdict: "Glamping with a view of Lady Liberty from a soaking tub is not something you forget. Collective Retreats on Governors Island is genuinely special."
4. Huttopia Adirondacks — Lake George Region
Nearly 300 acres of Adirondack woodland | Lake Luzerne, NY
Huttopia operates what Reddit's Adirondacks communities consider the region's best-equipped glamping destination. Nearly 300 acres of forested land near Lake George accommodate wood-frame canvas tents — some with full kitchens and bathrooms, all with wood stoves, BBQ grills, and private fire pits. A pool, lodge café, and camp store support the stay; at peak season, daily family activities run throughout the day.
Reddit points to Huttopia as the best option for families or groups who need both comfort and entertainment infrastructure in the Adirondacks without the rougher edges of standard camping.
Reddit verdict: "Huttopia Adirondacks is real glamping. Proper tent with real amenities, 300 acres of forest, Lake George right there. Perfect family trip."
5. AutoCamp Catskills — Hudson Valley
Airstreams and tiny houses in the Hudson Valley | Hunter, NY
AutoCamp brings its West Coast formula to the Catskills: polished Airstream trailers and architect-designed tiny houses arranged across a Hudson Valley property with hot showers, a well-equipped clubhouse, and a design aesthetic that photographs better than most hotels. Reddit's Catskills glamping discussions frequently recommend AutoCamp to travelers who want reliability and amenities while still sleeping among the trees.
The property generates predictable Reddit comments about price — AutoCamp runs premium — but the consistency of the experience earns it persistent recommendations, especially for first-time glampers hesitant about more rustic-adjacent alternatives.
Reddit verdict: "AutoCamp Catskills is the most plug-and-play glamping in New York. Airstream, hot shower, great clubhouse. Zero compromises."
6. Gatherwild Ranch — Germantown, Hudson Valley
Bohemian farm glamping on a working orchard | Germantown, NY
Gatherwild Ranch is Reddit's recommendation for travelers who want glamping to feel genuinely different from a hotel stay. The 50-acre orchard and meadow property offers a mix of bell tents, safari tents, and a vintage trailer, all arranged across open land with a distinctly artistic, farm-fresh atmosphere. Solo travelers, creative types, and small groups looking for a peaceful alternative to busier Hudson Valley properties repeatedly surface Gatherwild in New York glamping discussions.
The vibe is bohemian over polished — deliberately so — and Reddit users note that the experience rewards travelers who want wide-open space and a slow pace over a full amenity checklist.
Reddit verdict: "Gatherwild is the most genuinely relaxing place I've stayed in New York. Open orchard, bell tent, total peace. Underrated."
7. Glampful — Broadalbin, Capital-Saratoga Region
50 acres beside Great Sacandaga Lake | Broadalbin, NY
Glampful offers furnished safari tents on 50 private acres with direct access to Great Sacandaga Lake — and a program of on-site activities that Reddit's upstate New York outdoor communities highlight as a key differentiator. Kayaking, fishing, stargazing, live music, yoga, and campfire programming give the property a distinct energy that purely accommodation-focused glamping sites lack.
Reddit users note Glampful as a strong choice when the goal is an active outdoor long weekend rather than a passive luxury escape — the combination of lake access and activity slate makes it function more like a private resort than a hotel alternative.
Reddit verdict: "Glampful on Sacandaga Lake is incredible value. Plush safari tent, kayaks on the lake, live music on weekends. New York glamping hidden gem."
8. Hengarth Farm Yurts — Great Northern Catskills
Stargazing yurts on a heritage sheep farm | Northern Catskills, NY
Hengarth Farm occupies 101 acres of Catskill highland and operates fully furnished yurts designed specifically for stargazing, with panoramic mountain views, private bathrooms, and 360-degree night sky access from a summit deck. A mountain-top bar setup (bring your own), historic barn gathering space, and true wilderness surroundings make this one of the more distinctive properties in Catskills glamping.
Reddit astronomy and photography communities in particular recommend Hengarth for its genuine dark sky access — positioned well away from Hudson Valley light pollution — combined with the character of a working heritage farm.
Reddit verdict: "Hengarth Farm is the best dark sky glamping in New York. 360-degree mountain views, private yurt, real quiet. Very special property."
9. Malouf's Mountain — Beacon, Hudson Valley
Hillside glamping with shuttle access | Beacon, NY
Malouf's Mountain catches consistent Reddit mention for solving a specific New York glamping problem: car-free access. Located near Beacon — which is itself Metro-North accessible from Grand Central — the property runs a shuttle for guests without vehicles, and Reddit users note that gear can be transported to the site while guests hike in independently.
Beyond logistics, Malouf's earns praise for excellent showers, positioning that delivers genuine Hudson Valley views, and proximity to Beacon's strong arts and dining scene. Reddit communities consistently frame it as New York's best glamping option for city-based travelers without cars.
Reddit verdict: "Malouf's Mountain is the best New York glamping option without a car. Shuttle, great views, Beacon is right there. Highly recommend."
10. Purling Brook Cabins — Catskills
Waterfall-adjacent luxury cabins | Purling, NY
Purling Brook Cabins round out the list as the Catskills option Reddit glamping communities recommend most for romantic getaways specifically focused on nature immersion rather than social scene. Individual cabins combine rustic exterior charm with modern interior touches — hot tubs, fire pits, and the persistent ambient soundtrack of the brook — in a setting surrounded by Catskill forest and within reach of multiple waterfalls.
Reddit couples note that Purling Brook provides a level of privacy and natural setting that larger glamping properties, by necessary design, can't fully replicate at scale.
Reddit verdict: "Purling Brook Cabins are legitimately beautiful. Private, waterfall sounds all night, hot tub, wood cabin feel. Perfect couples retreat."
Frequently Asked Questions
When is the best time to go glamping in New York?
May through October covers the core glamping season across New York state. Finger Lakes wine harvest in September and October adds a particular draw; Catskills autumn foliage peaks mid to late October. Summer weekends book out quickly across most properties — reserve 2–4 months in advance for July and August.
Which New York glamping site is best for families?
Reddit consistently recommends Huttopia Adirondacks for families — its 300-acre forest setting, on-site pool, daily activities program, and proximity to Lake George make it the most fully equipped family glamping property in the state. AutoCamp Catskills is a close second for families who want reliability and amenities without needing programming.
Is glamping in New York accessible without a car?
Collective Retreats on Governors Island is the most accessible — reachable by free ferry from lower Manhattan. Malouf's Mountain in Beacon is Metro-North accessible from New York City, with a property shuttle for luggage. Eastwind Hotel in Windham has a bus stop within walking distance. For most other New York glamping properties, a car or rental is the practical solution.