15 Famous New York City Restaurants That Prove It's One of the Nation's Best Food Cities, According To Reddit
Ask anyone on r/FoodNYC, r/travel, or r/finedining what makes New York the greatest food city in the country and you'll get answers that fill entire threads. The case is easy to make. From corner delis that have been slicing pastrami since before most cities had a restaurant scene, to Michelin-starred Korean tasting menus reshaping how Americans think about fine dining — no other city comes close. Here are 15 famous NYC restaurants that prove the point, according to Reddit.
1. Katz's Delicatessen — The Most Iconic Deli on Earth
Katz's Delicatessen on the Lower East Side has been serving hand-carved pastrami sandwiches since 1888. Reddit's verdict in 2025 and 2026 is consistent: the pastrami is still among the best things you can eat in New York. Yes, it's crowded. Go anyway. Order: Pastrami on rye.
2. Le Bernardin — Three Michelin Stars, Zero Debate
Le Bernardin holds three Michelin stars and has for decades. Reddit's r/finedining calls recent meals here "an art form" and "a full journey." Chef Eric Ripert's seafood-focused French tasting menu ($325–$400+) appeared on the NY Times' 100 Best Restaurants in NYC 2025 list. Order: The tasting menu. The unlimited bread alone justifies the trip.
3. Carbone — The Italian-American Dining Room NYC Deserves
Carbone in Greenwich Village appears in virtually every Reddit NYC dining thread despite notoriously difficult reservations. Listed in the 2025 Michelin Guide, its theatrical mid-century Italian-American energy is unmatched. Order: The spicy rigatoni vodka — one of the most talked-about pasta dishes in the city.
4. Peter Luger Steak House — Brooklyn's Legendary Porterhouse
Peter Luger in Williamsburg is Reddit's most debated restaurant — cash-only, brusque service, strong opinions. What's beyond debate: the porterhouse for two has been one of New York's defining steak experiences since 1887. Redditors say visit at least once, skeptics included. Order: The porterhouse for two with the tomato-and-onion salad.
5. Russ & Daughters — New York's Irreplaceable Appetizing Store
Russ & Daughters on Houston Street has served smoked fish, caviar, and hand-rolled bagels since 1914. Reddit consistently ranks it among the handful of truly irreplaceable NYC food experiences. The adjacent Cafe earns equal passion. Order: The Classic Board — smoked salmon, cream cheese, capers, hand-rolled bagel.
6. Semma — The NY Times' #1 Restaurant in NYC for 2025
Semma in the West Village was named the number one best restaurant in New York City by the NY Times for 2025, and r/FoodNYC has been buzzing about it since. Chef Vijay Kumar's South Indian cooking — bold, deeply spiced, and unlike anything most New Yorkers had tasted — is credited with shifting how the city understands Indian cuisine. Order: The ghee roast and masala dosa.
7. Veselka — The Ukrainian Diner That Never Closes
Veselka in the East Village is the great NYC equalizer: a 24-hour Ukrainian diner where after-show crowds, neighborhood regulars, and tourists all share tables eating borscht and pierogies at 2 a.m. Reddit loves it for exactly this reason. No reservation required. Order: The borscht and potato pierogies.
8. Joe's Shanghai — Soup Dumplings That Built a Legend
Joe's Shanghai in Chinatown introduced generations of New Yorkers to xiao long bao, and Reddit still sends visitors there first on any Chinatown eating tour. The dumplings arrive in small bamboo steamers, thin-skinned and bursting with hot broth. There's a Reddit-documented technique for eating them without burning yourself — ask a local. Order: The crab and pork soup dumplings.
9. Atomix — Michelin-Starred Korean Tasting Menu Redefining Fine Dining
Atomix in NoMad holds two Michelin stars and appeared on the NY Times' 2025 Top 100 list. Reddit's fine dining community praises its immaculate Korean-inspired tasting menu as one of the most creative and technically precise dining experiences in America. Order: The full tasting menu. Reservations open months ahead.
10. L'Industrie Pizzeria — Reddit's Favorite Slice in the City
L'Industrie in Williamsburg is a tiny pizza shop where r/FoodNYC sends every visitor for the best slice in New York. The burrata slice appears in virtually every thread. It earns consistent superlatives from locals who've spent years working through every great pizza shop in the five boroughs. Order: The burrata slice. Arrive early — it sells out.
11. Momofuku Noodle Bar — Where the Modern NYC Food Scene Began
Momofuku Noodle Bar on First Avenue is where David Chang launched the modern New York ramen era in 2004. Reddit treats it as both historic landmark and active, worthwhile restaurant. The pork buns have never left and neither have the devoted fans. Order: The pork buns and, for groups, the legendary bo ssam.
12. Minetta Tavern — The Best Burger Hidden Inside a Steakhouse
Minetta Tavern in the West Village is famous for its steaks, but Reddit's community has a specific obsession: the Black Label Burger, made from a dry-aged proprietary beef blend, is consistently cited as one of the city's finest burgers. The tavern's dark wood and old-world atmosphere make every visit feel like a special occasion. Order: The Black Label Burger.
13. Great NY Noodletown — Chinatown's Late-Night Cantonese Classic
Great NY Noodletown in Chinatown closes at 4 a.m. and Reddit keeps recommending it for roast duck, salt-baked dishes, and noodles at prices that feel impossible in modern New York. It makes 2026 "best of" lists because it has never tried to be anything other than exactly what it is. Order: Roast duck over rice and soft-shell crab when in season.
14. Dhamaka — Bold Regional Indian Cooking Reddit Can't Stop Discussing
Dhamaka on the Lower East Side is one of the most energetically debated restaurants on r/FoodNYC. Chef Chintan Pandya's menu focuses on regional Indian dishes rarely seen in American restaurants — goat neck biryani, brain masala, raw mango chaat — creating a dining room that feels perpetually electric. It appeared on multiple 2025 best-of lists. Order: The goat neck biryani and the dal.
15. Oyster Bar at Grand Central — 100 Years of Seafood Under a Vaulted Ceiling
The Oyster Bar in the lower level of Grand Central opened in 1913. Redditors recommend it as a rite of passage — not just for the oysters (dozens of varieties rotating daily), but for the experience of eating beneath one of the city's great architectural ceilings. The pan roasts are a cult favorite. Order: A selection of East and West Coast oysters, plus a pan roast.
Why NYC Wins the Food City Debate
No other American city runs this deep across this many categories simultaneously. A single borough contains world-class Italian, French, Korean, Jewish deli, Cantonese, Indian, Ukrainian, and classic American steakhouse — and the other four boroughs add still more. Reddit has argued this endlessly and always arrives at the same conclusion: for range, history, and quality eating per square mile, New York City is unmatched.
Pro Tip from Reddit: Some of the best meals in NYC happen without reservations — a deli counter, a Chinatown basement, a pizza window in Williamsburg. Always leave room for the unplanned ones.
Related Food & Travel Guides
7 Charming Towns in the Hudson Valley With Outdoor Adventures, Incredible Restaurants, and Local Art
10 Best Glamping Sites in New York According to Reddit
Disclaimer: Restaurant information reflects February 2026 conditions. Hours, menus, pricing, and reservation availability change frequently. Always verify directly with each restaurant before visiting.